Thursday, February 2, 2012

Strangers on the Train


(http://www.postsecret.com/)
 This week, out of the twenty secrets posted on the website, this one stuck me the most because of its blatant truthfulness. I believe that as a society, it has become harder for each and every one of us (especially Americans) to start conversations with strangers. As this postcard depicts, even when we see people doing 'suspicious' things, like a person drawing pictures of others on the train, we hesitate to ask them about it. I think that this lack of being conversational is due to the increase in technology. Everyone nowadays is in their own little world on their iphones or laptops and could care less about what is going on around them. We no longer have conversations with people around us, only people we specifically choose to talk to.

I'd like to contrast this with my summer visits to Poland. I grew up in a fairly rural town called Nowy Sacz and I visit my family there every summer. People in this neighborhood do not own iPhones or any sort of 'new age' technology because it is too expensive and not as popular as it is in America. Instead of technology, they rely on conversations. It is not unlikely to go to the market and be stopped by strangers on the street who are saying "good morning" or "how are you today?" This type of interaction is VERY normal and it is even considered rude to not talk to a person you pass on the street, even if he or she is a complete stranger. To me, this type of social interaction is very pleasant and meeting new people every day is an amazing experience.

So what went wrong in America? I guess technology makes us feel that we do not need the rest of the world; we only need the people in our contact lists on our phones, since they are so easily accessible.

4 comments:

  1. First off, if I saw you drawling a picture of me I think I would be weirded out...but in a funny way like, "what is this guy doing." But technology, I feel, is to blame for our insociable tendensies. It is almost like we are too incompetent to be verbally active with those around us. I feel that emergent technology allows us to be in our own world. To be honest I found myself writing the way I text one time. I was quite embarrassed because I somehow felt that I was getting farther away from reality. Have you ever been on your phone playing an addicting game at an event and you look up and either no one is around you or the event is over? Sometimes technology can do the opposite from bringing us together.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Technology has definitely impacted social interaction with strangers. However, I have a hard time saying that this is a purely "American" fad. I went to visit my sister in California over break and I was so surprised to see how engaging people were there. I remember once getting on an elevator with my sister and an older man walked on. He started talking to my sister and I remember just standing there, thinking how weird it was to see that. It also happened when we went to the store or bought a cup of coffee. Maybe it was just the area or people, but it was an entirely different culture of interaction out there.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Does anyone else find that the bigger "social networking" has gotten, the less people actually communicate with each other face-to-face? Smartphones amplify this trend. Forget about asking some dude on the street directions if you are lost. Don't you have an iPhone for that? I blame the problem you highlight on a culture where everything has to be instantaneous. Text messaging and being able to social network from a smartphone train our brains to check Facebook repeatedly so that we are the most "up to date" on the information from our social circles. I don't think it's any coincidence that they call this feature on Facebook a "News Feed", implicitly giving Facebook a more important status than it deserves. Additionally, having this "News Feed" revolve around "us" keeps people more insulated from what is actually going on around them. I think it goes without saying that walking around everywhere with headphones on poses a potentially serious safety hazard to people. Nice post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. There's also some anecdotal evidence that social networking and texting and being perpetually ear-budded have actually had a significant effect on interpersonal interaction skills--things like reading body language, facial expressions, and social cues effectively. It hasn't been entirely lost, to be sure, but I've read some observations about a decline.

    If anyone finds a link to a credible source discussing this, I'd be curious to read it.

    ReplyDelete